One of these days they'll get me.  They'll make me change my way of cooking, and when they do, that'll hurt my product. The style of barbecue we have here in Lexington is very unique. I think it will start to fade away.

— Wayne Monk

Owner, Lexington Barbecue as quoted in Smokestack Lightning

Smoke Daddy's Review of Bartleys BBQ

Joint: 

Smoke Daddy, XO, and Phil Chelf would come back for the brisket, beans, and cobbler.  The ribs were nearly done, and if fully rendered would also be very good.  20+ year history and nice folks make this a pleasant surprise in strip center barbecue.   

MAIN FARE:Bartleys 3-meat

  • Brisket - Beefy & fully rendered.  Tender meat with just a bit of chew. Good. Not too much smoke, but it is evident around the edges.
  • Rib - Good color. Lightly rubbed. Good meaty flavor and finished with a sweet glaze. Mine was 'mostly done', But XO and Phil's needed more time in the smoker -- not fully rendered.
  • Sausage - Commercial texture with a 'unique' spice blend.  Spice profile clashes with the sauce.  Not a favorite.
  • Hot link - Richer flavor with a bit of kick.  Consistency is still commercial-style, but flavor is good.

OTHER FARE:

Bartleys Cobbler

  • Potato Salad - Soft taters. Very mild flavors in the mixture. A few bits of veggie for crunch/texture. Bland.
  • Slaw - Cream based sauce, but watery.  Leaf has lost some of its crunch. Very mild flavors... bland.
  • Pintos - Simple, but good flavors.  Beans are soft, and there's just a touch of spice on the finish. Nice.
  • Sauce - West Texas Style (Red, translucent, with flavor that doesn't cover the meat).
  • Banana Pudding - Standard mix with Nilla Wafers and banana slices on the bottom.
  • Cobbler - Apple/Peach mixture is spiced like an apple pie... with peaches as an added bonus! Robust cinnamon spices and crispy texture make this cobbler great.

ATMOSPHERE: Bartleys Firebox

  • Strip mall location - Bartley's has been here about 20 years.  They moved from Main St where City Hall bounced them from their original location citing eminent domain.
  • Nice folks using a J&R pit that is busy 24 hours a day.  
  • Moist towelettes on the table were a nice touch after the sticky (glazed) ribs.

Bartley's Bar-B-Que on Urbanspoon

Main Fare: 
7
Other Fare: 
6
Atmosphere: 
6

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.